How to Choose the Right Roofing Company in Steubenville

stritaroofing
May 23, 2025
3 min read

Updated: Jun 16, 2025

And Why the Right Choice Is Deeper Than You Think

Let’s be honest — hiring a roofing company can feel like gambling with your home. There’s a lot of noise, a lot of pressure, and often, very little trust.

But a roof isn’t just another line item. It’s the shield over your family. It deserves more than quick quotes and vague promises. It deserves reverence, honesty, and hands that treat your home like sacred ground.

At St. Rita Roofing, we’re not trying to be the flashiest name in Steubenville. We’re trying to be the most faithful.

So How Do You Actually Choose the Right Roofing Company?

Here are a few key things we encourage every homeowner to ask — whether you hire us or not:

1. Reputation You Can Actually Trace

Don't just look at stars — look at stories. Who’s talking about them in your town? Can you hear the difference in tone from their customers? Are they known for vanishing after the check clears, or for checking back in six months later?

We’re a newer name in Steubenville, yes. But we’re building our reputation one roof, one conversation, one act of integrity at a time.

2. Licensed, Insured, and Willing to Explain It

Any reputable roofing company should be licensed and insured — but also transparent about what that means. At St. Rita Roofing, we’re happy to walk you through it.We want you to know what’s protecting you, because trust is built on clarity.

3. Do They Prioritize Repair or Push Replacement?

Too many companies go straight to “replace the whole thing.” We don’t. Our first question is always: what’s best for the customer — not our commission. If a repair is the best option for the roof and the customer, well then we’ll repair it. If replacement is necessary, we’ll explain why without pressuring. We serve, not sell.

4. Are They In It for the Long Haul?

We’re not here for a season. We’re here to build relationships. That means:

Free follow-ups after storms
Maintenance membership options
Full transparency with pricing
And yes — prayers said and masses offered for you thorughout the year.

Not as gimmicks, but as gestures. Because you’re not a number to us.

5. Do They See Roofing as a Trade — or a Calling?

This might sound strange. But we see roofing as more than shingles and nails. We believe a roofer can carry the heart of a protector, a craftsman, even a priest. Because putting your hands to a roof — if done right — is putting your heart into a home.

And Steubenville deserves roofers like that.

You Don’t Just Need a Roofing Company — You Need a Partner

If you're looking for flash, we might not be your pick. But if you're looking for someone to show up on time, walk you through your options, respect your budget, and serve your home like it matters — we're ready.

Visit our website to:

Explore repair and maintenance options
Book a free inspection
Learn how we give back to the community
And discover what makes our St. Rita Maintenance Memberships more than just a subscription — but a commitment to your peace of mind, providing protection from above.